
Description
We have seen that God exists: one, eternal, all-powerful, all-knowing, and good. The next question is whether this God has spoken – whether He has communicated anything to us beyond what we can reason out from nature – and if so, how we would recognize it.
There are two common ways to answer “no.” The first is deism, which holds that God exists but has given no revelation beyond nature. The second is the spirit of much paganism, ancient and modern: that the divine is found through intuition, experience, and tradition rather than through any particular revelation, and that every path is as valid as another. I will discuss why both answers collapse, and then lay out how we can test a claim of revelation.
Note that the proof of God’s existence has already ruled out polytheism and pantheism on metaphysical grounds: there can be only one necessary being, and it cannot be the universe. That settles much of the question for the great pagan traditions of the East and West, whose gods are many or identical with nature. This page addresses something different: not what they believe about the divine, but how they claim to know it.
Deism
Deism gained prominence during the Enlightenment, and was popular among political intellectuals like the U.S. founding fathers. The basic idea is that God exists, but is not responsible for any revelation beyond nature. We can sort deist beliefs into two buckets. “Watchmaker deism” argues for an uninvolved God: He made the universe, then turned His back on it and let it run. “Providential deism” – which seems to be the true Enlightenment position – argues for a God who is involved, but has not communicated through special, binding, miraculous revelation.
Watchmaker deism has already been answered. The proof of God’s existence shows that the universe depends on God right now, at every moment, as a television depends on its power source. A God who wound up the universe and walked away is not the God that argument arrives at. So the serious form of deism is the providential one.
Providential deism is belief in a God who is involved in the universe, but has not produced miraculous revelation. Today, this often manifests in “moralistic therapeutic deism” – a pluralistic, nice-guy God with vague, lax moral expectations who mainly wants you to succeed, be happy, not hurt anyone, and go to Heaven. Most who hold it nominally belong to a religious tradition (think Christmas-and-Easter Christians). Taken to its logical conclusion, though, providential deism doesn’t hold up.
Consider the human race. Every culture in human history has had a preeminent religion or spirituality. Humans have an innate desire for purpose, social cohesion, and moral order. Worship is an integral part of the human experience. Some might dispute this, imagining candles in a church, but worship does not have to be formal to be worship. In the absence of divinity, men will worship ancestors, nature, money, pleasure, athletes, politicians – anything. But they will worship.
So the providential deist must admit that God made human nature for a reason, admit that human nature cries out for meaning and worship, and then claim that He didn’t bother to give us any explicit means to satisfy these needs. Often the deist will claim there is some generic, universal worship humans have lost to corrupt religious institutions. But history shows nothing of the kind. Left to our own devices, humans invent wildly different forms of worship, and the threads that recur among them are polytheism and, all too often, brutality – not a 21st-century humanistic deism. Ritual prostitution, human sacrifice, infanticide, ritual torture; Zeus, Krishna, Mars, Ra, Huitzilopochtli. The pagan era did not end because of some deistic enlightenment. What eliminated these practices and spread monotheism across the world was Christianity – a revealed religion, carried by an institution.
In fact, nearly everything the deist would consider worthy of this so-called universal religion – the unity of mankind, mercy, human dignity, care for the marginalized – was rare or absent before revealed monotheistic religion took hold. If the evidence suggests anything, it is not that people left to themselves have an innate capacity to worship God well. It’s that people need to be saved from the worship they concoct. If that is the case, man is in real need of God’s guidance.
Of course, revealed monotheistic religion did not exist throughout all of human history, a fact the religious must admit. A deist might contend that we are still waiting for the true religion. But it is perfectly sensible that God would wait to establish such a religion until the conditions were fitting; a cross-regional religion with a central authority would not have been possible in, say, the early ancient world. And massively influential revealed religions exist right now, have for thousands of years, have already achieved much of what deists would predicate of true religion – spreading monotheism and moral values like human dignity – and haven’t seen a serious new contender in a very long time. We have good reason to think that if God has spoken, His word is already here.
Paganism’s Insufficiency
If God has spoken, how do we find out what He said? There are two general frameworks for spiritual discernment. One answers with logos: reason, evidence, and the search for reliable authority. The other answers with mythos: intuition, experience, and tradition. My thesis is simple: a spirituality built on intuition alone, accepting every path as equally valid, has no principled foundation for calling anything evil – and in practice, even its own adherents abandon it the moment they need to.
Two Frameworks.
If you ask a classical theist why they believe in God, they’re usually going to propose God as the solution to concrete, universally recognizable logical concerns, like the origin and sustenance of the universe. Thomas Aquinas, for example, argues there are simultaneous causal regressions: you are sustained by your organs, they by cells, they by molecules, and so on. If every step of the regression relied on another, nothing would have causal power at all; a TV plugged into an infinite series of power strips would never turn on. So caused causes must terminate in an uncaused cause – God. Classical theists take a similar approach to religious doctrine, appealing to historical evidence of some divine authority communicating particular beliefs to the exclusion of contradictory ones.
The pagan approach, as it is usually practiced, works differently. It does not justify its spiritual systems by objective fact-finding and authority, but by intuition, experience, and tradition: the mythos takes priority over the logos. It’s not as if infants are regularly discussing taxes fresh out of the womb, such that we need reincarnation to explain it, or that rocks regularly start talking, such that we need animism. Rather, these beliefs are proposed on spiritual grounds and supported logically after the fact. (There have, of course, been pagan philosophers who reasoned rigorously about the divine – Plato and Aristotle among them, along with the Vedantic thinkers of India. But their reasoning pointed toward one supreme reality, not away from it.)
This approach leads to what I call “radical pluralism.” Gandhi demonstrated this mindset when, asked about his religious affiliation, he responded, “Yes, [I am a Hindu]. I am also a Muslim, a Christian, a Buddhist, and a Jew.” On the one hand, radical pluralism sounds uncontroversial – don’t bother each other with dogmas, live and let live. But there is a real tension here, because radical pluralism is a dogma. When the missionary appears promising the truth, the radical pluralist does not respond with arguments, but with the assertion that there’s more to life than truth. The difference is not one of facts, but of paradigms. So let us examine the paradigm.
Radical Pluralism
Radical pluralism markets itself as the harmless, enlightened alternative to dogmatic bickering. But a world where truth belongs to each individual is far from harmless. It offers no defense when intuition leads to dark places. If every intuition is valid, on what grounds can anyone condemn the one that says otherwise?
Consider these words: “These Christians who talk of men ruling this world, must stop. Man is nothing special; he is but a part of this world… [he must] acquire the right sense of proportion about what is above us, about how we are woven into this cycle.” These are not the words of a peaceful shaman. They are the words of Heinrich Himmler, architect of the Holocaust. My point is not that paganism inevitably leads to a Holocaust, nor that pagans are guilty by association with Himmler. My point is that a worldview with no objective standard above intuition is defenseless against intuitions like his – and Himmler, notably, used that very framing to reject the Christian idea of man’s special dignity.
The ancient pagan world included ritual prostitution, human sacrifice, infanticide, and ritual torture. Many hold that we have outgrown these things, that we can adopt paganism without endangering our psyches. But human nature hasn’t changed. Is it so difficult to understand the prevalence of human sacrifice among cultures that did not hold man in special regard – made in the image of God, with inalienable dignity – but considered him merely a part of nature? Is it difficult to understand how such an attitude could sustain inhumane social structures like the caste system, or lead Indian widows to voluntarily undergo sati, ritual burning upon the deaths of their husbands?
Behind the veil of inoffensive inclusivity, radical pluralism hides a deep spiritual poverty. Standing against another armed with the truth is a greater act of love than standing beside them in their error. There’s an old story about General Charles Napier, commander of British forces in India, encountering Hindu priests who complained about the outlawing of sati. They accused him of interfering with their cultural practices, to which he replied, “Be it so. The burning of widows is your custom… but my nation has also a custom. When men burn women alive, we hang them. Let us all act according to national customs.” I do not wish to glorify imperialism, but I do wish to glorify Napier’s words. In that moment he loved the Hindu widows with a greater love than their own priests did.
If you too believe Napier was right, you must ask yourself why. He was a foreign invader; he overrode centuries of custom, and likely even the stated consent of many widows. That doesn’t reflect a pluralistic, intuition-first mindset. It reflects a mindset that is logical, uncompromising, and grounded in an objective moral standard. And if you are a pagan and find yourself agreeing with Napier, you’re not alone. Gandhi – the Hindu-Muslim-Christian-Buddhist-Jew – argued against sati himself, on exactly these grounds. If radical pluralism were truly sufficient, Gandhi would have accepted sati as a valid custom. His refusal is a silent admission that reason is not merely a cheerleader for intuition, but its necessary master.
Those who seek the divine through reason operate within a shared framework where questions can be posed and answered, undergirded by the understanding that logical conclusions carry an obligation to assent. If Christians and Jews disagree, it’s like physicists arguing over competing theories. If radical pluralists disagree, it’s like people arguing over whose favorite color is better. But if reason oriented toward objective truth is the most powerful tool we have, why would we ever subordinate it to intuition? What sense does it make to use reason to settle solemn moral questions like sati, and then turn around and appeal to intuition to justify the spirituality that defines one’s whole life?
Are you tempted to disagree? Then I ask you this: if your disagreement is shown to be logical, do I have an obligation to assent to it? If yes, you concede that we have objective logical and ethical obligations, and reason must govern. If no, then making the argument at all defeats itself.
Testing Revelation
So we should expect God to speak, and we must use reason, not intuition alone, to recognize where He has. But there are many religions, each with rich histories and great depths of philosophy and theology. How can anyone who isn’t a lifelong historian sort through them? Two principles make the task manageable.
Group by shared premises. Imagine there were only ten religions on earth, and in four of them it is absolutely essential to believe the earth is flat. It would be absurd to study each of their unique merits when you could group them by that one premise and set them aside together. Likewise, it makes sense to group real-world religions by what they share, not by what is unique to each. That is why the proof of God’s existence can rule out every polytheistic and pantheistic tradition at once.
Use only decisive arguments. Once we’ve proven the earth is spherical, piling on further arguments against flat-earth religions would be patronizing and distracting. The argument is over. So only the most serious contradictions count as refutations. To qualify, a contradiction must (1) concern a core principle of the religion, or the basis for believing it, and (2) be unambiguous. That rules out cheap shots: that the Pentateuch must be false because it says God changes His mind (ignoring the many other figures of speech it uses for God), that the Quran describes the earth spread out like a carpet (which doesn’t mean the earth is flat), or that the Torah permits slavery (God could have good reasons to tolerate something imperfect, like condescending to the economic system of the time).
With those principles in place, what should a genuine revelation look like? At minimum:
(1) It should be consistent with what reason already shows about God. A revelation of many gods, or of a capricious, amoral deity, contradicts what we know of the one, good God and can be set aside.
(2) It should rest on public evidence, not private experience alone. Anyone can claim a private vision. A revelation God intended for all people should come with signs that others could witness and check – events in history, not only experiences in one person’s mind.
(3) It should be consistent with itself and with its own sources. A revelation that claims to confirm earlier scripture should not contradict it; one that claims to fulfill prophecy should actually fulfill it.
(4) It should provide a way to know what it means. If God speaks to correct our confusion, He would not leave His message so that every reader is the final judge of it; we should expect a visible means of settling disputes about what He said.
These tests apply to every religion that claims to speak for God – including Christianity. The pages that follow apply them in turn.
Conclusion
If God made humans with a thirst for the transcendent, there must be some proper way to satisfy it. But history shows that people left to their own devices invent wildly different forms of worship, often brutal ones; what ended those practices was not a natural enlightenment, but revealed religion. And intuition alone cannot tell us which way is proper, since radical pluralism has no foundation to condemn even the worst of its own fruits. We must approach the divine with the same seriousness we would bring to a widow in mortal danger: applying reason to search for truth, wherever it may lead, regardless of our own predilections.
A note for the seeker: although God did not give us innate knowledge of how to worship Him, He did give us reason. We should not expect a true religion to make perfect sense to us, as that would presuppose we already understand God – and if anything is clear from history, it is that we do not. The only thing we should expect of a true religion is evidence of credibility.
Two revelations in history rest on public events rather than private visions: God speaking to the whole nation of Israel at Sinai, and the resurrection of Jesus of Nazareth, the fulfillment of what began there. That is where we turn next.
