
Description
Infallibility means an incapability to be wrong under particular circumstances. If I had “mathematical infallibility,” you could give me a math test and know with absolute certainty that any question I didn’t leave blank is correct. Catholics and Orthodox both believe that the true Church, being the “pillar and foundation of the truth,” is infallible in defining universally binding doctrines of faith and morals (1 Tim. 3:15). Like the math test, this doesn’t mean the Church has the answer to everything all at once; it just means whatever doctrines the Church “hasn’t left blank” are true and binding. But of course, this is useless if we can’t tell which Church is the true one. How does Christ distinguish the true Church?
Christ established a visible body of shepherds through Apostolic succession, the passing on of the office of bishop by an unbroken chain of consecrations going back to the original twelve. By this, Christ left the Church a visible sign of His sanction. But there’s another problem. Today, there are three major Apostolic communions: the Catholics, the Eastern Orthodox, and the Oriental Orthodox. Each considers the others to be in error. There is only one truth, so only one can be “the pillar of truth.” I will show that the Catholic Church alone has a clear, visible, scriptural, and historical claim to the protection of the Holy Spirit in her teaching.
The Referee
Every religion examined on this site so far lacks one thing: a final, visible, divinely instituted authority. Paganism is eclectic by nature. Islam, Judaism, and Protestantism are each based on books, and books can be read many ways. These faiths are like sports without referees. A Norse pagan cannot authoritatively call a Celtic pagan’s worship right or wrong, nor one rabbi another, nor a Calvinist a Methodist. Without a referee, no one can be sure whether he is following God or simply his own desires or those of a persuasive leader; every dispute ends in a stalemate.
Apostolic succession narrows the field enormously. But the Apostolic Churches are divided too, and some have fallen into despair trying to discern between them. The differences are so technical – the procession of the Holy Spirit, the essence-energies distinction, Purgatory, and so on. They find it impossible to judge which Church is true by these means. And that’s a good intuition. It is impossible for most people. Many brilliant men who spent their lives studying the ancient languages, the theologians, and the scriptures came to heretical conclusions. The ordinary believer stands no chance. But precisely because this is impossible, we know God does not expect it. The Good Shepherd does not ask the sheep for more than they can do. This is why He communicates through signs. He condescends to the flock’s confusion by giving clear, recognizable signs of His presence – Sinai, Elijah’s offering, Jesus’ miracles, Pentecost, and so on.
Orthodox and Catholics agree that Apostolic succession is a visible sign by which ordinary people may recognize the Church. But it cannot be the only one, because several Apostolic communions are in schism. If Apostolic succession were the only visible sign, then God intended to give His Church a recognizable mark and failed, which no Christian can believe. So some other sign must also mark the true Church. To serve its purpose, this sign would need three characteristics. It must be visible, so ordinary people can recognize it. It must be exclusive, so that rival communions cannot reasonably claim it at once. And it must be divinely instituted, so that no one can reasonably charge that men invented it. The Catholic claim is that Christ provided exactly this: a referee.
The Papacy
The Catholic Church claims that the Bishop of Rome – the Pope – fulfills these three requirements. The premise is simple: scripture designates Peter as the leader of the Apostles. Rome was his last see, making the bishops of Rome his successors. As Peter was the Church’s rightful leader, so too are they. So far, you may be surprised to learn, the Orthodox would partly agree. Orthodox vespers call Peter “leader of the glorious Apostles and rock of faith,” and Pope Leo the Great “head of the Orthodox Church of Christ.” Many Orthodox grant that Rome once held first place among the Churches. The question is what exactly that place was. Catholics hold that Peter’s office was instituted by Christ for the unique role of keeping the Church one, which requires real authority over the whole Church and protection from error. The Orthodox hold that Rome’s primacy was one of honor and order, real but fallible.
The Catholic case can be made in three steps.
(1) Christ gave Peter a unique office over the whole Church. Not merely first place in honor, but real authority: the keys of the kingdom, the charge to strengthen his brothers, and the command to feed Christ’s sheep – all of them. The scriptural evidence follows below.
(2) That office continues in Peter’s successors at Rome. The Church’s need for a principle of unity did not die with Peter, any more than the Church did. The keys Christ gave Peter echo the keys of the royal steward in Isaiah – an office in the king’s household, which passed from one holder to the next. And Christ promised that the gates of Hades would never overcome the Church built on this rock: a promise for the Church’s whole life, not one generation. The earliest Christians located this office in Rome. Around 96 AD, while the Apostle John was still alive, the Church of Rome wrote with authority to settle a dispute in faraway Corinth (1 Clement). Around 180 AD, St. Irenaeus, bishop in Gaul and a student of a student of John, wrote that “every Church should agree with this Church, on account of its preeminent authority” (Against Heresies 3.3.2). Other sees honored Peter as a founder, but no other ever claimed his office over the whole Church; Rome claimed it from the beginning.
(3) Such an office must be protected from error when it binds the whole Church. If the successor of Peter can bind the whole Church in a matter of faith, and the Church can never be bound to error – for then the gates of Hades would have overcome her – then when he does so, God must protect him from error. This is what the Catholic Church defined at the First Vatican Council: when the Pope, as shepherd of all Christians, defines a doctrine of faith or morals to be held by the whole Church, he is protected from error.
Infallibility does not mean the Pope is a good or even pious man. It does not mean his private opinions are orthodox. It does not mean he cannot be corrupt, or do horrible things. All it means is that God prevents the Pope, the visible sign of the Church’s unity, from formally binding the Church to heresy. This gives the Catholic an “epistemic ground”: anyone may know his faith is the faith of the Apostles by ensuring his faith is Rome’s faith. The Orthodox disagree, holding that Rome’s leadership was a matter of honor, and that Rome could err. The rest of this page shows why that position is untenable: first, that scripture gives Peter’s office a unique character; second, that the early Church, East as well as West, recognized it; and third, that without it, the Orthodox have no principled way to identify the true Church at all.
Scriptural Support
Papal supremacy and infallibility took centuries to be fully clarified and formally defined. But this is no different from many other core doctrines, including the Trinity! And like the Trinity, the Papal office is revealed in scripture.
One note before we begin. Recognizing this sign and defending it against every plausible objection are two very different things. This isn’t unique to this argument – recognizing that your own two hands are in front of your face and defending this belief against a determined Cartesian skeptic are also very different things. This is simply the nature of argumentation. As this page gets into Greek translations and ancient councils, don’t lose sight of the fact that the beauty of the Papacy is its simplicity as a sign. I personally know a man who was raised an atheist, became a Christian, and chose the Catholic Church because Peter seemed to be the clearest point of connection back to Christ Himself, being the one visible unifying force with clear scriptural support. “If this ends up being the wrong one, I’ll just leave,” he said. He never did leave. Keep the thought of him with you as you continue reading.
The Rock
The plainest and most commonly used argument for the Papacy is Christ’s words to Simon at Caesarea Philippi. Following his confession that Jesus is the Messiah, Christ renames Simon Peter, which means “rock,” and says, “on this rock I will build my church, and the gates of Hades will not overcome it. I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven; whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven” (Matt. 16:18-19). The force of these words is intuitive, but we can draw out their power in three ways.
First, when God renames someone in scripture, it marks a new mission. Abram becomes Abraham, “father of a multitude”; Sarai becomes Sarah, mother of nations; Jacob becomes Israel. Jesus gives nicknames to others – James and John are the “Sons of Thunder” (Mark 3:17) – but Simon alone receives a new name that replaces his old one, explained by a commission. And consider the setting. Jesus had taught that a wise man builds his house on rock (Matt. 7:24-27). Now He brings the Apostles to Caesarea Philippi – a city built against a great rock face – names Simon “Rock,” and says He will build His Church on this rock.
Second, Matthew’s Gospel, written for a Jewish audience, plainly alludes to God’s words establishing Eliakim as the royal steward (2 Kings 18:18, 37) over King Hezekiah’s household: “I will place on his shoulder the key of the house of David; he shall open, and no one shall shut; he shall shut, and no one shall open. I will fasten him like a peg in a secure place” (Isaiah 22:21-23). Only the king himself exceeded the steward’s authority. Just as Joseph could say God had “made me a father to Pharaoh, and lord of all his house and ruler over all the land of Egypt” (Genesis 45:8), God says Eliakim “shall be a father to the inhabitants of Jerusalem and to the house of Judah.” Matthew presents Peter as the steward of Christ’s household, the Church – an office, with keys, that passes on.
Third, Matthew separates this scene from Christ giving the power to bind and loose to the other Apostles two chapters later (Matt. 18:15-20). Why, if not to mark Peter’s special role? All the Apostles have the power to bind and loose, and the Fourth Lateran Council (1215) teaches that Christ gave the keys to all the Apostles and their successors – but Peter received them first, and alone. As St. Cyprian put it – and Cyprian later clashed sharply with a Pope, so he is no flatterer of Rome – “[Christ] arranged by His authority the origin of [Apostolic] unity, as beginning from one. Assuredly the rest of the Apostles were also the same as was Peter, endowed with a like partnership both of honor and power; but the beginning proceeds from unity.”
Confirmations
Peter’s unique role receives numerous confirmations. At the Last Supper, Jesus tells the Apostles that “Satan has demanded to sift all of you like wheat,” but then addresses Peter alone: “I have prayed for you that your own faith may not fail; and you, when once you have turned back, strengthen your brothers” (Lk. 22:31-32). Peter speaks for the Apostles at Pentecost and before the Sanhedrin, performs the first Apostolic miracle, and pronounces judgments which God ratifies by striking the guilty dead (Acts 2-5). He opens the Church to the gentiles, and when challenged, gives an account that settles the matter (Acts 11:1-18). At the Council of Jerusalem, after much debate, it is Peter’s speech that settles the doctrinal question – salvation through grace, not the law – before James proposes the practical decree. St. John Chrysostom, the great hierarch of the East, explained why James presided in Jerusalem: Christ “appointed Peter teacher, not of the chair, but of the world.”
The Great(er) Commission
Each of the Synoptic Gospels ends with the Great Commission. But John places his Great Commission in his second-to-last chapter, and concludes his Gospel instead with this commission: “Jesus said to Simon Peter, ‘Simon son of John, do you love me more than these?’ He said to him, ‘Yes, Lord; you know that I love you.’ Jesus said to him, ‘Feed my lambs.’ A second time he said to him, ‘Simon son of John, do you love me?’ He said to him, ‘Yes, Lord; you know that I love you.’ Jesus said to him, ‘Tend my sheep.’ He said to him the third time, ‘Simon son of John, do you love me?’ Peter felt hurt because he said to him the third time, ‘Do you love me?’ And he said to him, ‘Lord, you know everything; you know that I love you.’ Jesus said to him, ‘Feed my sheep.’”
The threefold question surely heals Peter’s threefold denial. But notice the form the healing takes: not merely forgiveness, but a commission to shepherd Christ’s entire flock. And notice who wrote it down: the last living Apostle, writing decades after Peter’s death to churches in Asia Minor, by which time Rome had been led by several of Peter’s successors. Why would John end his Gospel this way, unless Peter’s office still mattered to his readers? And it comes right after a scene at the tomb which, as we’ll see, may point the same way.
The High Priest
Finally, for those who want to go deeper, a subtler pattern – not needed for the case above, but striking once seen. John’s Gospel can be read as a “walk through the Tabernacle.” John the Baptist introduces Christ as the “Lamb of God,” mirroring the altar of burnt offerings at the entrance (Ex. 38:1-7). The wedding at Cana, the “born of water and Spirit” passage, the woman at the well, and the healing at Bethesda recall the bronze basin for priestly purification (Ex. 38:8). John 6, where Christ feeds the 5,000 and calls Himself the bread from Heaven, reflects the table of the bread of the presence (Ex. 25:23-29). The “light of the world” discourses in the following chapters mirror the Menorah (Ex. 25:31-40). Jesus’ intercessory prayer, culminating in Jn. 17, reflects the altar where the High Priest burned incense, offering the people’s prayers to God as a sweet fragrance (Ex. 30:1-10).
The verdict of His trial – “I find no guilt in Him” – shows Him a worthy sacrifice, an unblemished lamb (Lev. 22:20). He is slain and placed within the tomb – the veiled Holy of Holies (Ex. 26:33). John underscores this when he describes two angels sitting where Jesus’ body had been, one at the head and one at the foot – like the two cherubim over the Mercy Seat of the Ark (Ex. 25:7-20). And Lev. 16 tells us that only the High Priest could enter the Holy of Holies. The message: Jesus is the High Priest who, through death, entered the Holy of Holies to atone for the people.
But the story continues. When Mary Magdalene reports the empty tomb, Peter and John run there together. John arrives first – but he does not go in. He waits, Peter enters, and only then does John follow (Jn. 20:4-8). This mirrors the night of Jesus’ trial, when Peter could not enter the High Priest’s courtyard until John spoke to the gatekeeper and brought him in (Jn. 18:15-16). Now the roles are reversed: John does not enter the new Holy of Holies until Peter goes before him. If this pattern is intended – and John’s Gospel is full of such patterns – Peter stands to John as the High Priest. But isn’t John already a shepherd, being an Apostle? Yes, and that’s what makes this so significant. Israel needed only one High Priest because it was one people in one land. A universal Church would need many bishops, many shepherds – and one who leads the shepherds, the source of their unity.
Historical Support
Again, although formal definition took a long time, the idea that Christ instituted the Papacy is not new. We have already seen Clement and Irenaeus. In the 4th century, Optatus said, “in Rome the episcopal chair was given to Peter; the head – that is why he is also called Cephas [“Rock”] – of the apostles; the chair in which unity is maintained.” A Roman synod under Pope Damasus I (as preserved in the later Decretum Gelasianum) declared that “the holy Roman Church has been placed at the forefront not by the conciliar decisions of other churches, but has received the primacy by [Peter].” St. Jerome, who translated the Bible from Hebrew, Aramaic, and Greek into Latin, wrote to Damasus, “I follow no leader but Christ and join in communion with none but the chair of Peter. This is the rock on which the Church [was] built.” St. Ambrose put it most simply: “where Peter is, there is the Church.”
In the 5th century, we begin to see this idea not just proclaimed, but carried explicitly to the conclusion that Rome cannot teach error. Pope Gelasius I gave a particularly thorough explanation: “This is just what the Apostolic See takes great care against – that because its pure roots are in [Peter’s] glorious confession, that it be marred by no crack of wickedness, no contagion. For if… such a thing were to [happen], how could we dare resist any error? Whence would we seek correction for those in error? … What are we to do about the entire world, if, God forbid, it were misled by us? … If [Rome] lose [faithfulness to the truth and communion], God forbid, how could anything ever be restored again, especially if in its summit, the Apostolic See, it became tainted, something God would never allow to happen.”
The broader Church came to accept the proposition. Pope Hormisdas ended the Acacian schism in 519 by having the Eastern bishops sign a profession of faith which declared: “It is impossible that the words of our Lord Jesus Christ, who said, ‘Thou art Peter, and upon this rock I will build my Church,’ should not be verified. And their truth has been proved… for in [Rome] the Catholic religion has always been kept unsullied… [and in Rome] is the whole and the true and the perfect solidity of the Christian religion.” The emperor backed the formula, and some signed reluctantly. But the same generation of Eastern bishops who later (metaphorically) dug up Theodore of Mopsuestia and Origen to condemn them as heretics accepted and signed this profession – they were not men who signed lightly what they considered heresy.
St. Maximus the Confessor, the most-cited author in the Philokalia, the great anthology of Eastern Orthodox spiritual writing, used the same logic to explain why Rome held firm against Monothelitism when the Eastern patriarchates had fallen: “For ever since the Word of God condescended to us and became man, all the Churches of Christians everywhere have held, and hold the great Church there as their sole basis and foundation, because, according to the very promises of the Lord, the gates of hell have never prevailed over her, but rather she has the keys of the orthodox faith and confession.” In a passage preserved in Latin, he likewise denounced the heretic Pyrrhus for offending Rome, “which from the incarnate Son of God Himself, and also by all holy synods, according to the holy canons and definitions, has received universal and supreme dominion, authority and power of binding and loosing over all the holy Churches of God.”
Pope Agatho wrote similarly to the Third Council of Constantinople (680): “Because… Peter was pronounced blessed by the Lord… he received… the duty of feeding the spiritual sheep of the Church; under whose protecting shield, this Apostolic Church of his has never turned away from the path of truth in any direction of error, whose authority, as that of the Prince of all the Apostles, the whole Catholic Church… [has] followed in all things. For this is the rule of the true faith, [which] remains undefiled unto the end, according to the divine promise of the Lord and Savior Himself [to Peter, that his] faith should not fail [and that he should] strengthen his brethren, [as my predecessors have done, and now I do] by divine designation.” The Ecumenical Council responded, “we acknowledge that this letter was divinely written as by the Chief of the Apostles.”
Many modern Orthodox apologists argue that, despite all this, the East never accepted Rome’s infallibility. They suggest that the East’s frequent praise of Rome as a bastion of purity was merely descriptive – a recognition of Rome’s excellent track record, not a belief that she could not err. Even granting this, the Orthodox position faces a difficulty. If Rome’s claims to supreme and unfailing authority were a grave error, then Rome was making them openly from the 4th century on – and the great saints of the East kept praising her. Sts. Athanasius and Chrysostom appealed to Rome when they were driven from their sees. Sts. Cyril, Basil, Theodoret, Sophronius, John Damascene, and Theodore the Studite, among many others, praised the purity of her faith. If they were praising a See which had betrayed the Apostles’ ecclesiology, on what basis can their other judgments – which form the foundation of Orthodoxy – be trusted?
Conciliar Responses
So this is the Catholic answer: the Pope is the visible sign of the true Church, and since the true Church is guided and protected by the Holy Spirit, he is protected from error when he binds the whole Church. One may have objections, but this is a coherent answer with scriptural and historical grounding. What, then, is the Orthodox answer? By what visible principle do they identify their communion as the true one?
The Orthodox will often say the Holy Spirit is the answer. But this begs the question; what we’re asking for is a visible sign that the Holy Spirit guides their Church. Other times they will say it’s because they kept the ancient faith while Rome strayed. But this begs the question as well; Rome says that she kept the ancient faith, which indispensably includes Peter. Many appeal to “reception theory,” the idea that a council’s teaching is confirmed when the whole Church receives it. But this is circular. Who confirms doctrine? The people of God. Who are the people of God? Those who hold the right doctrine. Rome could simply answer that she follows the reception of her own people!
Orthodox who recognize the circularity often appeal to the “Pentarchy” instead: the theory that the agreement of all five ancient patriarchs – Rome, Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch, and Jerusalem – rather than Rome alone, signifies the Spirit’s guidance. They often cite the Second Council of Nicaea’s explanation of why the iconoclast council of Hieria was not ecumenical: “[The Council of Hieria] did not enjoy the cooperation of the then Pope of Rome or his priests, neither by means of his representatives or an encyclical letter, as is the law for councils; nor did it win the assent of the patriarchs of the east, of Alexandria, Antioch, and the holy city, or of their priests and bishops… Nor did ‘their voice’, like that of the Apostles, ‘go out into the whole earth or their words to the ends of the world’, as did those of the six holy ecumenical councils.”
First, consider the source. This reasoning, though accepted by the East, was not written by the East. It was formulated by a Roman delegate, John the Deacon. And it names the Pope’s active cooperation (synergeia) as “the law” (nomos) for councils, while treating the assent of everyone else as a separate clause. That is, the quote implies the very opposite of the Pentarchy theory: Rome’s participation is required, while the others’ agreement confirms it. The Patriarch of Constantinople himself, St. Nikephoros, writing around 805, argued Hieria’s invalidity the same way: “Without [the Romans] no dogma can receive definitive approbation… for they preside over the episcopal office and they have received this dignity from [Peter and Paul].” Only after this does he note that the other patriarchal sees also took part.
So, first, the very testimony used to support the Pentarchy actually points back to Peter. Second, while the agreement of the patriarchs is a visible sign, it is neither exclusive nor divinely instituted. As to exclusivity, the five patriarchates are divided today, so their agreement cannot mark out the true Church. As to divine institution, scripture says nothing of it, and the five-patriarch arrangement wasn’t even complete until Chalcedon (451). Third, the theory contradicts history. The Council of Ephesus was received despite condemning Nestorius of Constantinople and breaking with John of Antioch – two of the four patriarchs of the time. Chalcedon was received despite condemning Dioscorus, Patriarch of Alexandria. The Third Council of Constantinople was received despite deposing Macarius, Patriarch of Antioch. In each case, the council stood with Rome against a dissenting patriarch. These points answer the Pentarchy theory specifically, and every theory that seeks the Church’s unity in councils without Peter.
Counterclaims
The Orthodox, of course, raise objections of their own to Papal supremacy and infallibility. The most common, with their answers:
First: Pope Vigilius. The Emperor Justinian exiled Vigilius’ predecessor, Silverius, and installed Vigilius as part of a plan to condemn the Three Chapters. Once installed, Vigilius changed his mind and refused. Under immense political pressure, he offered a reluctant condemnation; the unsatisfied Emperor declared that Vigilius had “excommunicated himself,” had the Second Council of Constantinople agree, and exiled him. Was Vigilius even a valid Pope? Yes; though his installation was irregular, a Pope’s legitimacy is confirmed by the Church’s peaceful and universal acceptance, which Vigilius received after Silverius died. Does his wavering refute Papal infallibility or supremacy? No; a secular ruler bullying a Pope into a coerced and revocable statement contradicts neither. And he was never actually excommunicated. The council went along with the Emperor’s declaration, but still waited until Vigilius died to elect his successor.
Second: Pope Honorius. Monothelitism, popular in his day, held that Christ had only one will. Patriarch Sergius of Constantinople, a Monothelite, wrote to Pope Honorius about the question. Honorius replied that Christ had one will, and decades later the Third Council of Constantinople condemned him by name alongside Sergius. This is the strongest case against Papal infallibility, and it should be faced squarely. Even so, it does not refute the doctrine. First, his letter was a private reply, not a definition binding the whole Church: no formal definition, no condemnation of contrary views, no appeal to his authority as Peter’s successor. Second, his words can be read in an orthodox sense – that Christ’s human will was never in conflict with His divine will, as when I say “my friend and I are of one will” – and some of his successors defended him on exactly these grounds. Third, when Pope Leo II confirmed the council, he did not condemn Honorius for teaching heresy, but for failing to stamp it out: he “permitted the immaculate faith to be subverted.” A Pope can be negligent, even gravely so. What infallibility excludes is a Pope formally binding the Church to error – and Honorius never did.
Third: Haec Sancta. This decree of the Council of Constance tried to end the crisis of three rival Papal claimants by asserting that a council has authority over the Pope. The prevailing Catholic view holds the decree invalid. Constance was not one continuous event: its early sessions, which produced Haec Sancta, were convoked by a claimant now recognized as an antipope. The legitimate Pope, Gregory XII, formally convoked the council afresh before freely resigning. His universally recognized successor, Martin V, approved only what the council had decreed “in a conciliar way” on matters of faith, and in his bull Inter Cunctas required those returning to the Church to affirm that the canonically elected Pope is the successor of Peter, “having supreme authority in the Church of God.” His successor Eugene IV approved the council only without prejudice to the “preeminence of the Apostolic See.” Some argue that the mere existence of rival claimants disproves the Papacy. But by that logic, the existence of many false christs would disprove the true one.
Fourth: other alleged Papal errors. Critics cite other cases, from Popes Liberius and John XXII to the claim that Pope Francis condemned capital punishment as intrinsically evil. These arguments are numerous and highly technical, and each turns on questions of coercion, private opinion, or what was actually defined. So I offer this general response: the very fact that one must resort to technical arguments to accuse the Popes of formal heresy is itself remarkable. Every other ancient patriarchate has been led, more than once, by plain and undeniable heretics. Sergius, the Monothelite who drew Honorius into error, was Patriarch of Constantinople. So was Nestorius, from whom Nestorianism takes its name. So was Cyril Lucaris, who embraced Calvinism! Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch, and Jerusalem have all been held by Arians, Monophysites, or Monothelites. One Nestorius in Rome – one Pope who formally bound the Church to heresy – is all it would take to disprove Papal infallibility. In two thousand years, no such case exists. What are the odds?
Conclusion
The Orthodox, like Catholics, hold that there is one true Church, and that Christ protects it from error. But since three major Apostolic communions each consider the others in error, Apostolic succession cannot be the only sign of the true Church. A fitting sign would have to be visible, exclusive, and divinely instituted – and the only sign that meets these criteria is the office of Peter. The East affirmed Rome’s role countless times before the schism. Without it, the Orthodox have no objective means of showing which Apostolic communion is the true one, and are left to conclude that Christ founded a Church no one can reliably identify.
Christ did not leave His flock a debate society. He left them a rock: a principle of unity, a foundation Hell can never overcome, a referee for every dispute. As St. Ambrose said, “where Peter is, there is the Church.”
